Second Thoughts

A series on cognitive offloading · by Aditi Menon

Second
Thoughts

just ask the ai. on second thought, let's think first.

How cognitive offloading shapes our cognitive capacities. As more of our thinking moves to AI, what happens to memory, judgment and attention? Essays and conversations with the people who study the brain.

Scroll to go in

Fig. 1 · Hippocampus

You remember where it lives.

The hippocampus helps turn what happens to you into memories that last. In 2011, psychologists found that when people expect to look something up later, they remember the fact less well and remember where to find it better.

Search made that trade small. AI makes it much bigger, because the thing you look up can now be the whole answer.

Fig. 2 · Prefrontal cortex

Who's doing the deciding?

The prefrontal cortex handles planning, weighing options and holding ideas in mind while you work through them. When a model drafts the argument for you, that work gets skipped.

So the question this series keeps coming back to is a simple one. What happens to a skill you stop practicing?

Fig. 3 · Parietal cortex

Where did your attention go?

Areas in the parietal cortex help steer attention, which decides what you notice and what slides past. Tools that answer instantly change what we bother to notice at all.

Some of that is a relief. Some of it might be a cost nobody has measured yet.

Fig. 4 · The whole network

None of it works alone.

Memory, judgment and attention run on networks that cross the whole brain, and they shape each other. Offloading one kind of thinking can ripple into the rest.

The people best placed to explain that are the scientists who study it, so most of this series is conversations with them.

Fig. 5 · Your brain, right now

This is your brain rn.

In a 2025 MIT Media Lab study, 54 people wrote essays on their own, with a search engine, or with ChatGPT while EEG tracked how strongly parts of their brains were talking to each other. Switch modes to see the pattern.

connectivity
memory
ownership

An illustration of the study's EEG connectivity results, not a real scan. The paper is a preprint and hasn't been peer reviewed yet. Read the study

On second thought,
think first.

New episodes go out on Substack. Start with whichever one catches your eye.

Written by Aditi Menon, CS and cognitive science at Rutgers. aditimenon.me LinkedIn

Episodes

Each episode looks at one part of the brain and what offloading to AI might be doing to it. Hover a plate to find it in the brain.